Ideas conquered long ago

Long ago, Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery conquered false claims that the Book of Mormon was fiction or that it came through a stone in a hat. But in recent years certain LDS scholars have resurfaced the false claims. To conquer them again, we have to return to what Joseph and Oliver taught.

Monday, September 21, 2026

Jour de Moroni - September 21

editorial modification of well-known
painting by Tom Lovell
Yesterday we did another fireside (in French) and I mentioned that September 21 is "Jour de Moroni" or "Moroni Day."

Latter-day Saints around the world recognize that September 21 is the day Moroni first appeared to Joseph Smith, as described first in Oliver Cowdery's Letter IV and six years later in Joseph Smith - History. 

We celebrate this date because it ushered in the Restoration. As Joseph wrote later, 

And again, what do we hear? Glad tidings from Cumorah! Moroni, an angel from heaven, declaring the fulfilment of the prophets—the book to be revealed.

(Doctrine and Covenants 128:20)

I suggested on another blog that people celebrate Moroni Day by reading the earliest and most detailed description of Moroni's first visit, which is in the Joseph Smith Papers here:


Here are two simple suggestions for Moroni Day that I would like the M2Cers and B2Cers to consider, based on unambiguous and authentic historical sources.

- Recognize and teach that it was Moroni who first identified the hill in New York as "Cumorah."

- Recognize and teach that it was not Moroni who met David Whitmer, Oliver Cowdery and Joseph Smith on the road to Fayette, nor was it Moroni who showed plates to Mary Whitmer.

Naturally, the M2Cers and B2Cers will say the historical sources were merely speculation and were wrong. And that's fine. They can believe and teach whatever they want. But they should at least teach their followers actual history instead of pretending these sources don't exist.
_____

Maybe if all Latter-day Saints around the world (and especially at BYU) honored Moroni and his legacy by teaching the full history we would be closer to the promised day when the Lord will reveal the rest of the plates.




Friday, September 18, 2026

Moroni Day 2026

Every September, Latter-day Saints around the world focus momentarily on Moroni's visit to Joseph Smith. 

This means people will be wondering, yet again, why the hill in New York is called the Hill Cumorah.


Well-informed Latter-day Saints know the reason: Moroni himself identified the hill as Cumorah the first time he visited Joseph Smith. 

But because some LDS scholars and their followers choose to believe (and teach) that the "real Cumorah" is somewhere else (Mesoamerica, Baja, Peru, etc.). Because these M2C and B2C influencers have considerable control over what Latter-day Saints know, the historical sources about Cumorah are not well know. 

A good example of this is a recent podcast by Scripture Central commemorating Moroni Day, which I discussed here:

https://scripturecentralpeerreviews.blogspot.com/2026/09/moroni-day-podcast-good-and-not-so-good.html

Despite the problems with that podcast, Scripture Central is much improved lately, having adopted a relatively neutral position on the setting of the Book of Mormon.

By contrast, to the extent they mention Cumorah at all, the M2Cers and B2Cers will do all they can in their podcasts, blogs, articles, etc. to lead Latter-day Saints to mistrust and reject the teachings of the prophets about Cumorah. 

But the rest of us can celebrate Moroni Day 2026 by reading and sharing all the historical sources with no problems. Here are some useful links:

https://www.mobom.org/cumorah-overview

https://www.mobom.org/cumorah-in-general-conference

On my LetterVII blog, I suggested people could celebrate by reading and sharing Letter IV.

https://www.lettervii.com/2026/09/moroni-day-2026-how-to-celebrate.html

BTW, if you're a day late celebrating Moroni Day, you're probably okay. We recognize September 21st as the date, but Joseph himself said it was likely after midnight, so on the 22nd.

:)



Tuesday, September 8, 2026

25 minute lessons


For all the conversation about the 25-minute lessons, it seems things went smoothly in most wards and branches. 

In our branch, everything worked great.

However, teachers and learners have adjustments to make. 

Because I've been a teacher and learner in a variety of settings inside and outside the Church and all around the world, I put together a short book that I hope some will find useful.

It's called 25-MINUTE GOSPEL CLASSES: SIMPLE PLANS TO TEACH, LEARN, AND CHANGE LIVES

Years ago I was influenced by Boyd K. Packer's book Teach Ye Diligently and I've included several relevant quotations from that book.

Right now, it's only available in Kindle (English and French). The printed version will be released in October. On the Kindle, you can download a sample and see what you think.

:)

https://www.amazon.com/25-MINUTE-GOSPEL-CLASSES-SIMPLE-CHANGE-ebook/dp/B0HFCCT4B5

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HJ31WHCP

Monday, September 7, 2026

D-Day and no more contention

We're living in Normandy, France, about 10 km from Utah Beach. Utah Beach was the westernmost of the five landing areas of the Normandy Invasion of World War II.

Across the street from us is the Hotel de Ville, decorated with lots of flags.

There are flags from France, Canada, the USA, the UK, the EU, and even Germany. One of the restaurants down the street has a sign on the window that reads "Deutsch gesprochen" (German spoken).

Even in September, our village is crowded with tourists from all over the world, including many Germans. It's wonderful to enjoy the peace here among nations that fought viciously during World War II.

Fighting wars to produce peace is how King Benjamin achieved "no more contention" as explained in the verses leading up to Mosiah 1:1.

I mention this because so many good things are happening in the world today.

Even among people who disagree about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon, there is lots of potential for "no more contention." 

All we have to do is agree to use the FAITH model of analysis.

:)

_____




Wednesday, September 2, 2026

Columbus' voyages

 

https://x.com/marcportermagee/status/2094541364994232692?s=20

This is a better way to visualize Columbus’ voyages than the traditional way (that shows him traveling through a modern map).. It looks a lot crazier and more daring when you see it as a trip into the unknown.




Monday, August 31, 2026

More Baja propagandizing: avoiding the FAITH model

I am continually amazed at how difficult it appears to be for LDS apologists (and critics) to pursue clarity, charity and understanding.

It is simple, really.

For clarity, just start with Facts. Then explain your various Assumptions, Inferences, and Theories, then conclude with your Hypothesis. Trust your audience to make informed decisions.

It's the FAITH model of analysis.

Very simple. 

Yet hardly anyone does it. 

The latest example comes from the Stick of Joseph YouTube channel. On my Letter VII blog, I've been assessing their podcast about Cumorah and Baja. 


Look at the juxtaposition of this title with the graphic. The table in the graphic censors Oliver Cowdery's Letter VII to omit (hide) Oliver's statement of fact. Then the title of the podcast says "The Hill Cumorah Historical Accounts: Truth and Tradition."

How could any podcast get more Orwellian than this?

Here are the first two parts of the review.

Part 1.

https://www.lettervii.com/2026/08/baja-sophistry-cumorah-and-baja.html

Part 2

https://www.lettervii.com/2026/08/baja-sophistry-cumorah-and-baja_0524624390.html

The critics are just as bad. 

Thus we have Informed Saints, the Stick of Joseph, the Interpreter, Mormon Stories, and lots of others who seem determined to prevent their viewers from making informed decisions. 

Apparently it is more profitable to confirm the bias of viewers than to inform viewers, but still...

I hope podcast viewers/listeners will start insisting that the podcasts they follow adopt the FAITH model of analysis going forward.

Friday, August 21, 2026

Casey Griffiths on Hello Saints podcast with Pastor Jeff

Casey Griffiths, an awesome BYU professor, met with Pastor Jeff. I discussed the conversation here:

https://www.lettervii.com/2026/08/casey-griffiths-fumbles-on-cumorah.html

This is yet another good example of how ignoring (or rejecting) historical sources leads to confusion and disbelief.

We wonder, why don't our scholars just tell people about the historical record and let them make informed decisions for themselves?

Maybe next time...