I often point out that 80-90% of what Scripture Central does is great. Apart from M2C and SITH, they offer lots of useful resources.
They are doing a series on Come Follow Me that is excellent. Here's an example:
Keep up the good work!
BOOK OF MORMON SETTING. Many Latter-day Saints still believe what the prophets have taught about the New York Cumorah/Ramah. President Nelson: "Good inspiration is based upon good information." Here, we share good information from original sources that corroborates the prophets. We support the Church policy of neutrality, which promotes unity by recognizing multiple working hypotheses. We encourage all interested parties to do the same, all in the pursuit of clarity, charity and understanding.
I often point out that 80-90% of what Scripture Central does is great. Apart from M2C and SITH, they offer lots of useful resources.
They are doing a series on Come Follow Me that is excellent. Here's an example:
Keep up the good work!
It continues to surprise me how many things there are to discuss on this blog. We have a long way to go to achieve full clarity, charity, and understanding, but we're getting closer as more people strive to become peacemakers (see nomorecontention.com).
SITH update.
I was asked to prepare a more detailed analysis of the origins of SITH, specifically the 1829 Jonathan Hadley article, so I in the pursuit of clarity, charity and understanding, I put it in a comparison table, here:http://www.ldshistoricalnarratives.com/2023/10/update-on-jonathan-hadley-and-sith.html
MacKay and Dirkmaat (fine scholars, awesome people, and BYU professors) are among the most prominent proponents (along with John Dehlin, the Interpreter, and Mormonism Unvailed) of the stone-in-the-hat narrative (SITH). They claim that Joseph Smith personally started SITH by relating it to Jonathan Hadley in Palmyra in 1829 when he was seeking a publisher for the Book of Mormon.
However, their narrative consists of imaginative mind reading and creative assumptions because Hadley never claimed he met Joseph Smith. MacKay and Dirkmaat rely on Hadley's 1829 article which is arguably ambiguous (it requires a stretch of the imagination to make it so). But Hadley's 1842 article goes into more detail and explains it was only Martin Harris who came to his print shop. In their books, MacKay and Dirkmaat forgot to mention the 1842 article, depriving their readers of the full story.
_____
Multiple working hypotheses update.
Around the world, people seek to make informed decisions. Those who grew up with the Internet have little interest in controlled narratives. They reject censorship and manipulation. More and more they reject the legacy media narratives that present only one side of issues. People want to hear a variety of perspectives.
This is one reason why legacy LDS apologists, such as the Interpreter and Book of Mormon Central, have less and less credibility, despite spending millions of dollars to promote their SITH and M2C narratives. Likewise, legacy critics such as Mormon Stories that rehash their dogmatic critical narratives over and over are monotonous and boring.
New podcasters are rising who seriously and authentically explore multiple working hypotheses about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon and other issues.
Among them are the Stick of Joseph, Mormon Book Reviews, Gospel Tangents, Mormonism with the Murph, CWIC Media, and ScriptureNotes.
To their credit, two legacy LDS apologists have started appearing on the authentic podcasts: Kirk Magleby and Brant Gardner. They are both articulate, careful scholars, and great guys. They've been doing a good job explaining M2C and SITH.
It would be even better if they could convince their legacy apologist sites, Scripture Central and the Interpreter, respectively, to be more open and honest about other faithful narratives (particularly those that still believe what Joseph and Oliver said), but there are strong institutional barriers to that happening. We remain hopeful, but realistic.
Meanwhile, the authentic podcasters are providing wonderful, enlightening content that enables people to make better informed decisions.
To cite two examples. Brant's interviews with the Murph on M2C and SITH were very helpful, as I discussed here:
http://www.ldshistoricalnarratives.com/2023/08/sith-narrative-explained-by-brant.html
http://www.ldshistoricalnarratives.com/2023/08/brant-gardner-on-book-of-mormon.html
BTW, people have asked me to do video reviews of these and other podcasts, but time is short and I figure informed viewers can assess the SITH and M2C narratives as well as I can anyway. But in the next few months I may have some free time during some trips I'm taking, so we'll see.
_____
M2C on Stick of Joseph
Stick of Joseph recently posted two important videos, one by Kirk Magleby and one by Jonathan Neville.
Kirk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vW2hkI7OXLU
Jonathan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDPao-SVUyY
Kirk made some excellent points, such as this:
23:30 having this old world geography approaching consensus nails historicity. Joseph Smith could simply not have come up with this stuff. It is beyond human capacity. It truly shows how divine and authentic and true to antiquity this culture is. But it also sets a nice precedent for how to go about the methodology which we're going to then apply over the new world. And number one we need a few anchor points.
Kirk then relates some anchor points in the Old World, such as how we know where Jerusalem is, the Red Sea, etc.
But this is exactly the problem with M2C. Joseph and Oliver gave us the ultimate anchor point in the New World--the hill Cumorah in New York.
Yet Kirk rejects the only specific anchor point (I call it a pin in the map) that Joseph and Oliver gave us!
How does Kirk explain that?
First, he claims Joseph learned about Book of Mormon geography in 1841 from a popular illustrated book by Stephens and Catherwood and that Joseph wrote or endorsed speculative articles in the Times and Seasons in 1842 that quoted extensively from the Stephens books. (I was surprised that Kirk resorted to this argument. It was the topic of my first book on LDS Church history and the two subsequent books. I understand the M2C argument based on the Stephens books, but it is so highly speculative compared with the direct, unambiguous statements from Joseph and Oliver that I hope more people realize that, as Kirk admits, M2C relies entirely on the speculative Stephens argument.)
Second, Kirk says Joseph and Oliver were ignorant speculators who, along with their contemporaries and successors, misled the Church about Cumorah (although he doesn't articulate that quite so directly, which is where the problem of clarity arises in all these discussions).
42:15 Stick of Joseph: so you don't think that Moroni, he would have given any information that would have really led Joseph Smith to believe where the Book of Mormon happened?
Kirk: No, I seriously doubt that. There's there's very little evidence in in the historical record that Moroni was revealing those kinds of things.
Comment. "very little" is a dodge because there is far more evidence of the New York Cumorah/Ramah in the historical record than there is that Joseph accepted M2C--for which there is zero evidence. For example, we can all read the Wentworth letter from March 1842, published in the Times and Seasons over Joseph's signature (unlike the Stephens editorials), where he says "I was also informed concerning the aboriginal inhabitants of this country, and shown who they were, and from whence they came; a brief sketch of their origin, progress, civilization, laws, governments, of their righteousness and iniquity, and the blessings of God being finally withdrawn from them as a people was made known unto me: I was also told where there was deposited some plates on which were engraven an abridgement of the records of the ancient prophets that had existed on this continent."
With that knowledge, Joseph dug up Hopewell mounds in Ohio, Indiana and Illinois, declaring they were evidence of the divine authenticity of the Book of Mormon and describing those states as the "plains of the Nephites." But to M2Cers such as Kirk, none of this is evidence because it contradicts their M2C theory.]
Stick of Joseph: So kind of the idea, like, because you know I think everyone would agree that we don't believe that the prophets are infallible. Sometimes we don't act that way but we'll say it, but so we don't believe that Joseph Smith was infallible. So you would say that when it comes to Book of Mormon geography and the majority of his thoughts on where the Book of Mormon happened, that that that falls in kind of the fallible, that he just didn't know and he was doing the best...
Kirk: They were his opinions. He had a more informed opinion than yours or mine but nonetheless at the end of the day they were Joseph's opinions. And he showed himself able to improve his opinion based on better data and that's exactly what we see when he gets his hands on Stevens and Catherwood.
Comment. Obviously, this is Kirk's opinion that they were Joseph's opinions. Oliver explicitly stated that the New York Cumorah/Ramah was a fact, and Joseph endorsed Oliver's declaration multiple times. Joseph's mother explained it was Moroni who identified the hill as Cumorah the first time he met Joseph, etc. By now, everyone should know the historical record. And surely they would if Kirk's organizations, Book of Mormon Central and Scripture Central, provided more clarity instead of obfuscation about the historical record.
The second point, that Joseph "improved his opinion" based on the Stevens book, is pure conjecture, as we've discussed at length. Not unreasonable conjecture; people can infer that Joseph somehow read the two thick volumes of Stephens' work within a week, with no one noticing or commenting, and then months later, during a time when Wilford Woodruff said Joseph hardly had time to sign documents they prepared for him, Joseph somehow wrote lengthy anonymous articles that he never publicly acknowledged, cited or quoted.
But even at that, far from "opining" that Cumorah was in Mexico, Joseph wrote a letter, published above his signature like the Wentworth letter, reaffirming that he learned about Cumorah before he even got the plates (D&C 128:20).
Stick of Joseph: yeah, okay, well that's a good understanding because I think that's really where kind of the break-off is as we talk to people like Wayne May, and we're going to be talking to other heartlanders as well, I would say that's a fundamental difference. They put Joseph Smith above the geophysical data, the scientific, the science, history and so that starts and then they're looking for the geodata and the science history based on Joseph Smith's early statements.
Kirk: That's absolutely correct.
Comment. This is one reason why Kirk is awesome. He understands the core issue here, to some degree. Yet his organization, Book of Mormon Central refuses to acknowledge this distinction on its website. Rather than enabling its viewers/followers to make informed decisions, Book of Mormon Central censors the Heartland approach and has its employees and followers attack Heartlanders on social media and in private meetings.
And Kirk agrees that it's not a difference in extrinsic scientific data, because there is plenty of data to support both M2C and Heartland (as well as other narratives); instead, it's a difference in whether we start by believing or by rejecting what Joseph and Oliver taught.
Stick of Joseph: Okay and what we're saying is you need to use the text as your primary source.
Kirk: The text is primary.
Comment. In my interview, I pointed out that Kirk's claim here is bogus. The text is not primary; Kirk's interpretation of the text is primary. Everyone who has developed a concept for Book of Mormon geography uses the text. That's axiomatic. But people disagree on the interpretation of the text, with each one claiming their own interpretation means they are using the text as their primary source.
It's comparable to the innumerable Christian denominations who all claim the Bible is primary, but they can't agree on even basic doctrines because of their different interpretations (multiple working hypotheses).
That's one of the purposes of the Book of Mormon itself, to provide non-Biblical clarification. That's why we have modern prophets.
Starting with Joseph Smith.
Kirk's position is irrational, actually. There is no reason to look for Book of Mormon events in the Americas if we rely solely on the text. The text never mentions America or even the western hemisphere. Even when explaining his approach, Kirk goes outside the text to rely on his belief that Joseph learned from the Stevens books.
The alternative approach that seems more logical to me is to look at what Joseph and Oliver said about the setting. They were the President and Assistant President of the Church, respectively. They were the First and Second Elders of the Church, the recipients of the Priesthood and the temple keys. Kirk's position that they misled everyone about the New York Cumorah/Ramah (M2C) thwarts the whole point of having prophets.
The M2C position outright rejects what Joseph and Oliver (and their contemporaries and successors) taught about Cumorah. Instead, they prefer arguing over the interpretation of the text, and they construct an artificial "consensus" among like-minded scholars and then train the youth of the Church to think the same way by using the BYU fantasy map (or, for Spanish speakers, their detailed M2C map), while hiring and funding only those young wannabe scholars who first adopt their M2C dogma.
M2C has produced the problem Paul wrote about long ago:
11 And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers;
12 For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ:
13 Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ:
14 That we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive;
(Ephesians 4:11–14)
_____
Bottom line.
The legacy critics and apologists are being supplanted by the far more honest, open and useful podcasters such as Stick of Joseph and the others I've listed.
Kudos to Kirk and Brant for appearing on some of these shows, but now let's hope they move to the next step and persuade their legacy apologist sites to engage in real dialogue as we pursue clarity, charity and understanding to reach no more contention.
![]() |
| Lord of the Rings map |
![]() |
| BYU map location for "Cumorah" |
The first element in the pursuit of clarity, charity and understanding is clarity. For that reason, from time to time we expose logical fallacies.
We can always tell when people make weak, losing arguments because they resort to ad hominem* attacks, the dumbest of the logical fallacies. An ad hominem argument attacks the person making the argument, not the merits of argument. It's a diversion tactic employed by those who realize their own positions lack merit or rationality. It's an excuse for ignoring the weaknesses of their own arguments.
People who depend on others' ignorance, apathy and/or irrationality to sustain their arguments usually end up resorting to ad hominem arguments because their arguments cannot withstand scrutiny.
It's a common tactic today among critics of the Restoration. They accuse Joseph Smith of personal failings as an excuse to justify their rejection of the Restoration, including the Book of Mormon. As Oliver Cowdery explained, "an excuse was wanted--and an excuse was had."
A month before he died, Joseph Smith responded to the ad hominem arguments made against him throughout his life.
I never told you I was perfect— but there is no error in the revelations which I have taught— must I then be thrown away as a thing of nought?
During Joseph's lifetime, critics made incessant ad hominem arguments against him and his family and associates. The 1834 book Mormonism Unvailed was replete with such arguments. Even today, critics and some faithful scholars reiterate the ad hominem arguments.
In response, Oliver Cowdery wrote Letters II and III. In Letter II, he pointed out that the biblical prophets whom modern Christians claimed to believe had all been persecuted during their lives. He then observed
But in reviewing the lives and acts of men in past generations, whenever we find a righteous man among them, there always were excuses for not giving heed or credence to his testimony.
The people could see his imperfections; or, if no imperfections, supposed ones, and were always ready to frame an excuse upon that for not believing.— No matter how pure the principles, nor how precious the teachings—an excuse was wanted—and an excuse was had....
The savior came in form and fashion of a man; he ate, drank, and walked about as a man, and they said “Behold, a man gluttonous, and a wine bibber, a friend of publicans and sinners!”
You see an excuse was wanting, but not long wanting till it was found—who would follow a dissipated leader? or who, among the righteous Pharisees would acknowledge a man who would condescend to eat with publicans and sinners?
This was too much—they could not endure it.
An individual teaching the doctrines of the kingdom of heaven, and declaring that that kingdom was nigh, or that it had already come, must appear different from others, or he could not be received.
If he were athirst he must not drink, if faint he must not eat, and if weary he must not rest, because he had assumed the authority to teach the world righteousness, and he must be different in manners, and in constitution, if not in form, that all might be attracted by his singular appearance: that his singular demeanor might gain the reverence of the people, or he was an imposter—a false teacher—a wicked man—a sinner—and an accomplice of Beelzebub, the prince of devils!
https://www.josephsmithpapers.org/paper-summary/history-1834-1836/58
_____
The New Testament relates the story of Saul/Paul and how people used his persecution of the saints against him even after his conversion. Even the saints initially rejected him because of his past conduct.
We meet Saul when he participated in the stoning of Timothy.
57 Then they cried out with a loud voice, and stopped their ears, and ran upon him with one accord,
58 And cast him out of the city, and stoned him: and the witnesses laid down their clothes at a young man’s feet, whose name was Saul.
59 And they stoned Stephen, calling upon God, and saying, Lord Jesus, receive my spirit.
60 And he kneeled down, and cried with a loud voice, Lord, lay not this sin to their charge. And when he had said this, he fell asleep.
(Acts 7:57–60)
2 And devout men carried Stephen to his burial, and made great lamentation over him.
3 As for Saul, he made havoc of the church, entering into every house, and haling men and women committed them to prison.
(Acts 8:1–3)
1 And Saul, yet breathing out threatenings and slaughter against the disciples of the Lord, went unto the high priest,
2 And desired of him letters to Damascus to the synagogues, that if he found any of this way, whether they were men or women, he might bring them bound unto Jerusalem.
(Acts 9:1–2)
_____
* from wikipedia:
Ad hominem (Latin for 'to the person'), short for argumentum ad hominem, is a term that refers to several types of arguments, most of which are fallacious. Typically this term refers to a rhetorical strategy where the speaker attacks the character, motive, or some other attribute of the person making an argument rather than attacking the substance of the argument itself. This avoids genuine debate by creating a diversion to some irrelevant but often highly charged issue. The most common form of this fallacy is "A makes a claim x, B asserts that A holds a property that is unwelcome, and hence B concludes that argument x is wrong".
Everyone is busy. Time is short, so we defer to experts. In his 1776 book Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith explained that we all become more prosperous through specialization and exchange. We visit a doctor so we don't have to go to medical school ourselves. We buy tickets on airplanes so we don't have to attend flight school.
In the LDS context, we defer to historians and scholars to do research we don't have time to do ourselves. We recently honored the completion of the printed volumes of the Joseph Smith Papers, for example.
But that deference leaves us vulnerable. We risk accepting their scholarly interpretations as facts.
I was reminded of this when I saw this slide from Scripture Central's celebration of "Moroni Day" 2023.
![]() |
| (click to enlarge) |
This is one of the "go-to" quotations we often see from BMC (Book of Mormon Central). And they almost always misspell the author's name.
It's Austin Farrer, not Austin Farrar.
This is a tiny detail, but it exemplifies a much larger problem with LDS scholarship. In the interests of clarity, charity and understanding, let's take a look.
_____
Some time ago I was curious about the context of this quotation. I bought an original copy of the 1965 book that is usually cited. That's when I realized the name was misspelled and the citation was incorrect.And that's the same pattern Jack's followers have employed in promoting M2C.
_____
Jack used the Farrer quotation in an awesome article titled "The Power of Evidence in the Nurturing of Faith." In Echoes and Evidences of the Book of Mormon, edited by Donald W. Parry, Daniel C. Peterson and John W. Welch, 17-53. Provo, UT: Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, 2002.
https://archive.bookofmormoncentral.org/content/power-evidence-nurturing-faith
In an important sense, evidence makes belief possible. I am very impressed by the words of Austin Farrar in speaking about C.S. Lewis and quoted by Elder Maxwell on several occasions: “Though argument does not create conviction, lack of it destroys belief. What seems to be proved may not be embraced; but what no one shows that ability to defend is quickly abandoned. Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish.” 18
18. Austin Farrar, “Grete Clerk,” in Light on C.S. Lewis, comp. Jocelyn Gibb (New York: Harcourt and Brace, 1965), 26; cited in Neal A. Maxwell, “Discipleship and Scholarship,” BYU Studies 32/3 (summer 1992):5.
The citation to Elder Maxwell's article shows he spelled the name correctly, although his citation was wrong. Presumably E. Maxwell's research assistant got it wrong and no one checked it.
E. Maxwell's quotation:
Do not underestimate the importance of what you do as articulators. In praising C. S. Lewis, Austin Farrer wrote:
Though argument does not create conviction, lack of it destroys belief. What seems to be proved may not be embraced; but what no one shows that ability to defend is quickly abandoned. Rational argument does not create belief, but it maintains a climate in which belief may flourish.1
I am thankful to those who help to provide the needed “climate.”
1. Austin Farrer, “Grete Clerk,” in Jocelyn Gibb, comp., Light on C. S. Lewis (New York: Harcourt and Brace, 1965), 26.
https://byustudies.byu.edu/article/discipleship-and-scholarship/
Jack Welch simply copied the erroneous citation and reformatted it, but then also misspelled the name.
Again, it's not a serious problem that Jack misspelled Farrer's name. Nor is it a serious problem that Jack perpetuated Elder Maxwell's erroneous citation. Mistakes happen. Maybe Jack's research assistant copied it wrong and Jack just didn't notice.
But this misspelled word is a signature. As the slide at the beginning of this post shows, everyone who misspells Farrer's name is simply copying--and perpetuating--Jack's error.
And everyone who uses Jack's erroneous citation is probably copying his without referring back to Elder Maxwell's original erroneous citation that Jack copies in the first place.
We wonder, how long will these errors persist?
_____
Before moving on to another more serious example, you might be wondering why Elder Maxwell got the citation wrong in the first place.
![]() |
| Table of Contents |
![]() |
| Page 26 |
Farrer's entire article is worth discussing, which I've done elsewhere.
_____
Let's return to the problem of perpetuating errors.
In that book, Jack entirely censored a very key point about the trip from Harmony to Fayette, which is that the messenger took the abridged plates from Harmony to Cumorah before going to Fayette.
That's why the messenger declined David Whitmer's offer of a ride to Fayette.
And that's why David always remembered the encounter as the first time he heard the word "Cumorah."
Yet Jack, to promote his M2C theory, changed the actual Church history to claim that "The plates were carried to Fayette by Moroni in a bundle on his back" without mentioning the detour to Cumorah.
I wrote about that here:
https://www.bookofmormoncentralamerica.com/2017/12/opening-heavens-but-censoring-history.html
Because Opening the Heavens has become a standard reference, many authors refer to it instead of the original sources. Ordinary readers have no idea that Jack deliberately changed the history to avoid mentioning Cumorah.
This has led to the censorship of Cumorah in the Saints books, the Gospel Topics Essays, and other materials. It has also led to the fake identification of the messenger as Moroni, an error introduced by historian Andrew Jensen that contradicts both what Mary Whitmer said and what Joseph Smith said. As related by David, Joseph identified the messenger as one of the Three Nephites.
For more on that topic, see https://www.lettervii.com/p/moroni-and-nephi.html
While Jack's misspelling of Austin Farrer's name and his repetition of an erroneous footnote are not major problems, the pattern of people simply copying Jack's work and perpetuating errors is a major problem.
Jack's obsession with M2C has infected all of Book of Mormon Central and its affiliates.
How much longer will this pattern continue?
Some slides from my presentation at the Book of Mormon Evidence conference on September 16, 2023, where I was the concluding speaker.
I often say that about 80% of what Book of Mormon Central (and Scripture Central) do is great work.
Here's a good example. Kudos to Scripture Central and Tad Callister.