Ideas conquered long ago

Long ago, Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery conquered false claims that the Book of Mormon was fiction or that it came through a stone in a hat. But in recent years certain LDS scholars have resurfaced the false claims. To conquer them again, we have to return to what Joseph and Oliver taught.

Wednesday, November 1, 2023

The M2C mind virus

One of the most frequent questions people ask me is why Book of Mormon Central (BMC) and its allies continue to promote the M2C mind virus while also suppressing alternative faithful interpretations about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon. 

Specifically, BMC excludes (and encourages attacks on) geographical models that put Cumorah/Ramah in New York.

Elon Musk recent explained the problem in the context of a similar mind virus.


A year after Elon Musk bought Twitter, he finally explains WHY: He says that the niche ideology that turned San Francisco into a "zombie apocolypse" would historically be geographically isolated, and the fallout would therefore be limited. But Twitter gave that philosophy an "information technology weapon," which it could use to spread that mind virus to the whole planet unopposed. Musk: "In order for the mind virus to propogate it must suppress oppossing viewpionts." Rogan: "Because it doesn't stand up against scrutiny?" Musk: "Correct." Musk cared enough about stopping this virus that he spent $40 billion to do so.

Tuesday, October 31, 2023

Hadley article on Academia.edu

Because the Hadley article is so important, I uploaded a revised version to academia.edu at this link:

https://www.academia.edu/108771925/The_1829_Jonathan_Hadley_account_of_the_translation_of_the_Book_of_Mormon

Thanks to all those who provided review/input.

Friday, October 27, 2023

Comparison of approaches to Book of Mormon historicity

Recently I found a copy of a book published in March 2015. It was a first edition of my book The Lost City of Zarahemla, which discusses the articles in the 1842 Times and Seasons that led to the development of the Mesoamerican/Two-Cumorahs theory (M2C). I'll discuss it more next week because those articles are apparently still fundamental for the M2C believers. 

When I wrote that book, I thought that a new perspective on those articles might lead to a reconsideration of the assumptions and inferences that led to the development of M2C. However, I underestimated the extent of the investment many M2C scholars had made in their M2C worldview.

I'm fine with people believing whatever they want to believe. I enjoy understanding different perspectives and interpretations. It's fun and interesting. Which makes it all the more disappointing when others, particularly LDS scholars and their followers, focus more on defending their own beliefs instead of understanding what other faithful LDS believe and why they believe it.

The insular, closed-minded psychology of both apologists and critics continues to amaze me.

That's why I prefer the pursuit of clarity, charity and understanding, as discussed on nomorecontention.com.

_____

The pursuit of clarity, charity, and understanding includes the use of comparison tables. At the risk of oversimplification and generalization, comparison tables can clarify differences for everyone to see. This helps people make informed decisions.

In my latest book, The Rational Restoration, I quoted Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker's observation about how to correct logical fallacies.

Under the right circumstances—the alternatives are available for comparison side by side, and the wording of the alternatives leaves nothing to the imagination—people can think their way out of the fallacy.

The ongoing discussions about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon need much more clarity, charity and understanding. 

The FAITH model discussed in The Rational Restoration shows us how everyone can agree to the facts that are actually facts. From there, people diverge because of their assumptions, inferences, and theories. Clarity helps everyone distinguish between facts and the other elements, enabling people to make informed decisions.

The following comparison table offers an overview of the approaches taken by some of the people currently involved in the discussions. Although an oversimplification, it is a useful framework to understand some of the ongoing discussions and their various proponents. 

Relative acceptance of what Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery taught

 

All

Some

None

 

Cumorah location

New York

Mexico

Fictional

 

Type of analysis

Rely on the text, historical and extrinsic evidence, rational thinking

Rely on the text, historical and extrinsic evidence, rational thinking

Rely on sarcasm, anger, taking offense, making ad hominem arguments, etc.

Rely on the text, historical and extrinsic evidence, rational thinking

 

Clarity:

Seeks clarity through specific comparisons and full disclosure

Avoids clarity by refusing specific comparisons and omitting contradictory evidence

Avoids clarity by refusing specific comparisons and omitting contradictory evidence

Avoids clarity by refusing specific comparisons and omitting contradictory evidence

 

Charity:

Assume everyone acts in good faith

Assume everyone acts in good faith

Assume fellow LDS who disagree are wrong, racist, nationalist, ignorant, etc.

Assume LDS are ignorant, deluded, dishonest, and/or abusive

 

Understanding:

Multiple working hypotheses: Fine with people believing whatever they want, no compulsion to convince, seek to understand, then to be understood

Compulsion to convince that only one conclusion is allowed: M2C.

Compulsion to convince that only one conclusion is allowed: M2C.

Compulsion to convince that only one conclusion is allowed: Book of Mormon is fiction.

 

Principal authors

Wayne May,

Rod Meldrum, Jonathan Neville

Jack Welch, Kirk Magleby, BMC staff

Dan Peterson, Stephen O. Smoot, Mike Parker

Dan Vogel, John Dehlin, Jeremy Runnels

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Monday, October 23, 2023

Symposium report - October 20, 2023

Last Friday I spoke to around 350 people in Lehi, Utah, at the Land of Promise symposium. I discussed the two sets of plates and other topics for over an hour, followed by another hour of Q&A. Many in the audience had never heard of the events in Church history I discussed even though they were otherwise well-informed about Church history.

The most common question, as usual, is "Why haven't I heard this before?" 

It's cool to see more and more people, both Latter-day Saints and others, become aware of the original, authentic historical record about the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon. 

Here are some of the slides I showed.




















Thursday, October 19, 2023

Land of Promise symposium

I've been invited to speak at the Land of Promise symposium in Nephi, Utah, on Friday, Oct 20th. Here's the link:

https://bookofmormondiscoveries.com/

It's cool to see a variety of perspectives. 

They asked me to post this announcement:

The Fall Land of Promise Expo takes place next weekend:

   - October 20th - 21st in Nephi, Utah! 

   - at The Hive: 645 East 700 North in Nephi

 

Come and listen to our amazing speakers.

Strengthen your testimony as you bask in the spirit of the truths they will share with us.

 

Speakers include: Wayne May, Kevin Price, Dana Young, Russ Barlow, David Doane, James Harris, David Hocking, David Lindsley, Jonathan Neville, Pamela Openshaw, Farrell Pickering, Hannah Stoddard, Boyd Tuttle and Steven Wilden. 

 

You won’t want to miss Wayne’s report on his exciting finds from this summer!

 

Click on the link below and grab your passes now!

PURCHASE EXPO PASSES

(https://sas.strideevents.com/events/fall-land-of-promise-expo/2023/tickets)

 

 

To help facilitate your stay here in Nephi please find the following list of motels and RV parks available in our area:

 

Best Western Paradise Inn of Nephi

1025 S Main St, Nephi  

(435) 623-0624

 

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Nephi

1507 S Main St, Nephi

(435) 250-8777

 

Super 8 by Wyndham Nephi

1901 S Main St, Nephi

(435) 250-0888

 

Economy Inn & Suites Nephi

885 E 100 N, Nephi

(435) 250-9000

 

Whitmore Mansion B&B Nephi

110 S Main St, Nephi

(385) 201-9073

 

Rollin' Home RV Park Nephi

2888 So. 4 Mile Rd, Nephi

(435) 250-8800

 

Jones High Country RV Camp Nephi

899 S Main St, Nephi

(435) 623-2624

Friday, October 13, 2023

Fundamental truths

This explains everything we talk about on this blog.

“Don’t just follow the trend... boil things down to the most fundamental truths you can imagine and you reason up from there. This is a good way to figure out if something really makes sense or if it’s just what everyone else is doing.” | Elon Musk

It makes sense to boil down Church history regarding the origin and setting of the Book of Mormon. Then we see what Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery said all along makes the most sense. Joseph translated the engravings on the plates by means of the Urim and Thummim, and it's a fact that the hill Cumorah/Ramah is the same hill in western New York where Joseph obtained the plates.

Simple, clear, and rational.



Wednesday, October 11, 2023

50 years ago - lands of promise

Discussions about Book of Mormon geography sometimes involve the question of where Lehi's "land of promise" was. That's a valid question that people can reach different conclusions about. 

The key point for us today is that wherever Lehi's land of promise was located, in our day, the land of promise for everyone on Earth is the place where they already live. The idea of one "land of promise" changed 50 years ago.

Unlike in Orwell's Animal Farm, where some were "more equal" than others, no land today is more of a land of promise than anywhere else.

_____

The New Testament says Abraham "sojourned in the land of promise." (Hebrews 11:9)

Lehi sought and obtained a different "land of promise." For me, it seems obvious that the "land of promise" for Lehi was eastern North America, but I'm fine with people believing whatever they want. 

The Jaredites were brought to "a land of promise" as well. (Ether 2:9) People debate whether that was the same as Lehi's land, but again, it seems obvious from Moroni's account. 

"And now I, Moroni, proceed to give an account of those ancient inhabitants who were destroyed by the hand of the Lord upon the face of this north country." (Ether 1:1) Where is "this north country" to which Moroni referred?

Moroni himself told Joseph Smith directly that the record was "written and deposited not far from" Joseph's home near Palmyra. https://www.josephsmithpapers.org/paper-summary/history-1834-1836/69

This is simple, clear, and unambiguous. "as plain as word can be." 

The reality that many people have reinterpreted these passages to mean something else does not change what we can all read. But that's all fine.

_____

The phrase "land of promise" occurs with this frequency in the scriptures:

OT (0) NT (1) BM (22) DC (3) PGP (1) [Jonathan Edwards used the phrase 15 times]

The phrase "promised land" occurs with this frequency:

OT (0) NT (0) BM (21) DC (0) PGP (0) JE (31)

The phrase "lands of promise" occurs only in the Book of Mormon (twice).

The significance of the phrase "lands of promise" became apparent 50 years ago when President Harold B. Lee gave one of the longest General Conference talks in recent times. 

In it, he endorsed the principle that the land of promise in our day is the area where we live. In our day, there is no need for Latter-day Saints to gather to any particular area. Instead, every part of the planet is a land of promise.

This is an important principle for everyone to remember so we don't think one "land of promise" is better than another "land of promise."

https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/general-conference/1973/04/strengthen-the-stakes-of-zion?lang=eng

We have also been promised by the Lord: “Behold, and lo, I will take care of your flocks, and will raise up elders and send unto them. Behold, I will hasten my work in its time.” (D&C 88:72–73.)

Today we are witnessing the demonstration of the Lord’s hand even in the midst of his saints, the members of the Church. Never in this dispensation, and perhaps never before in any single period, has there been such a feeling of urgency among the members of this church as today. Her boundaries are being enlarged, her stakes are being strengthened. In the early years of the Church specific places to which the Saints were to be gathered together were given, and the Lord directed that these gathering places should not be changed, but then he gave one qualification: “Until the day cometh when there is found no more room for them; and then I have other places which I will appoint unto them, and they shall be called stakes, for the curtains or the strength of Zion.” (D&C 101:21.)

At the Mexico City Area Conference last August, Elder Bruce R. McConkie of the Council of the Twelve, in a thought-provoking address, made some comments pertinent to this subject, and I quote a few sentences from his address:

“Of this glorious day of restoration and gathering, another Nephite prophet said: ‘The Lord … has covenanted with all the house of Israel,’ that ‘the time comes that they shall be restored to the true church and fold of God’; and that ‘they shall be gathered home to the lands of their inheritance, and shall be established in all their lands of promise.’ (2 Ne. 9:1–2.)

“Now I call your attention to the facts, set forth in these scriptures, that the gathering of Israel consists of joining the true church; of coming to a knowledge of the true God and of his saving truths; and of worshiping him in the congregations of the Saints in all nations and among all peoples. Please note that these revealed words speak of the folds of the Lord; of Israel being gathered to the lands of their inheritance; of Israel being established in all their lands of promise; and of there being congregations of the covenant people of the Lord in every nation, speaking every tongue, and among every people when the Lord comes again.”

Elder McConkie then concluded with this statement, which certainly emphasizes the great need for the teaching and training of local leadership in order to build up the church within their own native countries:

“The place of gathering for the Mexican Saints is in Mexico; the place of gathering for the Guatemalan Saints is in Guatemala; the place of gathering for the Brazilian Saints is in Brazil; and so it goes throughout the length and breadth of the whole earth. Japan is for the Japanese; Korea is for the Koreans; Australia is for the Australians; every nation is the gathering place for its own people.”